Sunday, March 4, 2012

DRJ #4



Initial Reaction: The pacing of Acts IV and V is way faster than the beginning acts. Action abounds, and each bit is more unbelievable than the those preceding. My favorite part is when Hamlet's ship gets attacked by pirates, and he escapes. I thought at first Hamlet might have invented this as explanation for his escape, but all the research I've done suggests that, within the play, his boat was indeed attacked by pirates. Of course. I can't say that any part or character reminds me of anything in particular, but the abundance of increasingly ridiculous goings-on (a pirate attack, a duel, and the death of everyone) has an over-the-top quality that reminds me of theater in general. Perhaps I'm evading the question.
Character Analysis: I find Gertrude perplexing. I believe she has genuine love for Hamlet; I didn't find any evidence to suggest otherwise, and throughout the play she tells him she loves him. In other areas, though, she is twisted. There is no way that Gertrude could get married to her late husband's brother SO shortly after Hamlet Sr.'s death had Claudius and Gertrude not already been having an affair, and Hamlet suggests that his mother is an unfaithful who** several times. Without Gertrude, we could not have the story. Claudius might not have had enough motivation to kill Hamlet Sr. if there were no Gertrude to win; Hamlet would not have felt so betrayed; and thus, the need for revenge would not have been present. Even the ghost of Hamlet does not wish for any harm to come to her, suggesting that (up until the end), she was probably a good wife.
Theme Analysis: Although it is not the most significant theme in the last acts, I noticed that the characters brought up the treatment of wealthy people vs. those without money a few times. When the gravediggers are talking to eachother in act V, Second Clown (gravedigger) says to the First Clown gravedigger that Ophelia would not be getting a Christian burial, had she not been wealthy, as she committed suicide. 5.1.20-21 goes, “If this had not been a gentlewoman, she should have been buried out o' Christian burial.” Later on, when Hamlet is interacting with the irritating Osric, he says essentially the same thing; Osric is not fun to interact with, but since he has land and money, he is treated well. By having both a peasant and royalty reflect on the issue of money buying good treatment, Shakespeare uses contrast to emphasize his point.

4 comments:

  1. I found the Acts IV and V more ridiculous and unbelievable than the preceding acts as well. Pirate ships, Hamlet being able to fake the letter and conveniently having his father's signet ring, and Hamlet and Laertes fighting in Ophelia's grave? You've got to be kidding me. I agree, I think Gertrude genuinely loved Hamlet, but her desire to stay in power and keep up her self-image led her to ultimately side with Claudius rather than Hamlet. I like your theme, I noticed that too. I think that having prestige and money makes one likable, no matter how crazy one is.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like the wealthy/poor them thing you pointed out.

    ReplyDelete
  3. As for me I also agree that Gertude is a good wife. There is no proof leading the audience to become aware that she killed her lover Hamlet Senior she also may not have known that the king killed his brother for this is not shown in the play either. I believe she married Polonious for Hamlet to have a better life, in the play we show the caring side of her when she and Hamlet are alone in her room she shows care for him when he talks to the " ghost". Moreover, we are shown that there is a good relationship between the mother and the son when the king says it would be better to stay in Denmark, soon his mother agrees and pleas Hamlet to stay in denmark he then finally agrees he will and notice he only answers to his mother not his uncle.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'm also confused about Gertrude. I don't really think she was cheating on Hamlet Sr before his death, but then what are her motives with Cladius? Maybe she was very insecure and didn't feel she had another choice?

    ReplyDelete